Files
turnstone/docs/settings.md
T
Patrick Buckley 33ace975d2 feat(models): default-deny governance and admin UI for per-alias backend auth
Follow-up to the per-alias Entra OBO/app-identity backend auth: the
console write path now applies default-deny field classification, the
admin shelf gains full backend-auth support, and the session/registry
rebind machinery is hardened for config changes landing under live
sessions.

Console write gate:
- Default-deny classification: any non-neutral change to a row that is
  or becomes dynamic requires admin.mcp plus validation; the provably
  auth-neutral columns are enumerated (MODEL_AUTH_NEUTRAL_FIELDS) and a
  live-schema classification test forces every future column to be
  classified. The derivation is a pure function (_derive_auth_gate)
  with unit-pinned exclusivity invariants.
- Two-tier validation mirroring the MCP oauth_obo validator: the row
  tier (audience allow-list) runs on every gated write; the posture
  tier (OIDC configured, token store present) runs on pair changes and
  on enable-arming.
- Pure-disable carve-out: disabling a dynamic row is de-escalation and
  is never blocked — admin.models suffices and validation is skipped,
  including for rows with corrupt or skewed stored values.
- Capabilities are compared canonically (key order, integral floats),
  the audience compare normalizes both sides, and staging an audience
  on a static row is refused on both write twins.
- Calibrate writes the capabilities column under an enforced
  confinement invariant with a compare-and-swap persist.

Admin shelf:
- Backend-auth section with a per-open constraints fetch
  (GET /model-definitions/auth-constraints: audience allow-list, grant
  profile, dynamic modes), datalist audience suggestions,
  server-defined modes preserved on round-trip, and permission-aware
  visibility built on cache-skew-safe helpers shared through auth.js.
- Refused live-registry swaps surface as an amber registry_warning on
  the write, delete, reload, and calibrate responses; audit rows carry
  auth_gated / auth_disarmed markers visible in the audit view.

Registry and sessions:
- The encryption-key requirement for dynamic auth is enforced inside
  ModelRegistry.reload() itself — nodes refuse with 503 and the
  console records coord_registry_error — and reload bumps the
  generation before the map swap so a racing reader can never pair a
  stale generation with new maps.
- resolve()/resolve_binding() return the generation from inside the
  registry lock; sessions rebind per send on generation change with
  atomic client/provider/config commits, fallback-first handling of
  removed or unconstructable aliases, and judge/limiter resets only
  when the binding actually changed.
- Mint refusals record per-user causes surfaced in the per-turn
  heartbeat logs; misconfiguration warnings are deduplicated with
  bounded state.

Verification: 10417 tests (99 added on this branch), a 71-scenario
browser harness over the real admin shelf, and a live rfc8693
token-exchange e2e run (MCP legs verified end to end; the model-leg
scope gap is tracked as #955 under a narrow known-gap signature).

Closes #950.
2026-08-03 20:11:28 -07:00

18 KiB

System Settings

See also: Settings Architecture diagram

The system settings feature provides database-backed configuration for server nodes. Settings are stored in the system_settings table and managed through the admin API or console Settings tab. This replaces config.toml for non-bootstrap settings on server entry points, while the CLI continues to read config.toml directly.

Overview

Settings follow a typed registry pattern: every storable setting has a SettingDef entry in settings_registry.py with type, default, description, validation constraints, and a restart_required flag. Unknown keys are rejected at the API boundary.

At runtime, ConfigStore loads all settings from storage into an in-memory cache. Reads are lock-free dict lookups on an immutable snapshot. Writes acquire a lock, persist to storage, and swap the cache atomically.


Precedence

Settings resolution differs between entry points:

Entry point Chain
Server (turnstone-server) CLI flag > ConfigStore > registry default
CLI (turnstone) CLI flag > config.toml > argparse default

The server's apply_config() ignores config.toml sections that overlap with ConfigStore. A startup warning is logged for each overlapping key, directing users to the admin Settings API.


Per-Model Sampling Overrides

The global model.temperature, model.max_tokens, and model.reasoning_effort settings serve as cluster-wide defaults. Individual models can override these via per-model settings in the model_definitions table (admin Models tab).

Resolution order for sampling parameters:

Priority Source
1 (highest) Per-model override (set in Models tab)
2 Global default (set in Settings tab)
3 Registry default (code)

When a per-model override is NULL (empty in the UI), the global default is used. Switching models via /model <alias> re-resolves sampling parameters from the new model's overrides or global defaults.

Model backend authentication

Model definitions support three backend credential modes:

auth_mode Identity sent to the model gateway
static The definition's stored api_key.
entra_obo A caller-delegated Entra access token minted from that user's captured OIDC credential.
entra_app A shared app-identity token minted with Turnstone's OIDC client credentials.

Dynamic modes require an exact obo_audience resource App ID URI. Before an admin can save one, an operator must add that literal audience to model.auth_audience_allowlist (comma- or newline-separated). Wildcards and base-URL host matching are intentionally unsupported, and a row whose effective mode is static refuses to store a new non-empty obo_audience on either create or update — an audience cannot be staged for a later flip (clearing a stale value, or re-saving it unchanged, stays allowed). On a row that is (or becomes) dynamic, every change except the tuning fields — context window, temperature, max tokens, reasoning effort, and the two reasoning-persistence toggles — also requires admin.mcp; service tokens do not bypass this capability-escalation gate. The one exception is de-escalation: a save whose only gated change is switching enabled off is a pure disable, needs only admin.models, and skips validation — a de-listed audience must never block disarming its own row. The gate is deny-by-default: a field counts as auth-relevant unless it is provably neutral, so re-enabling a disabled dynamic row, re-pointing its base_url, or swapping its provider or alias all escalate.

Validation runs in two tiers, matching the MCP oauth_obo write rules. Row validity — the audience is allow-listed — applies to every gated write that touches a dynamic configuration, so a revoked audience can be neither silently re-pointed at a new base_url nor re-armed by an enable flip. Deployment posture — the token encryption key installed, single sign-on configured, and the grant profile valid and able to carry the mode — is checked when a write chooses the mode/audience pair and when it re-enables a disabled dynamic row (arming is the flip that resumes minting, so it must meet what minting needs); other edits to an existing row stay open if the deployment's posture changed after it was saved (its mints warn at runtime instead). Refusals name their cause and echo the configured value.

One asymmetry to be aware of: the write path counts a transient discovery outage (enabled=false, retryable) as configured, but the mints themselves require discovery to have completed — a config saved during an outage starts minting only once any authenticated request heals discovery. Until then calls warn and follow the fail-open/fail-closed policy above.

entra_app is supported only with [oidc] obo_grant_profile = "entra". Judge, output-guard, perception, utility, and sub-agent lanes inherit the session's effective user for entra_obo. The perception memo is partitioned by that principal as well as alias and content hash, so a result authorized as one user cannot be served to another. Scheduled and wake-driven work retains the workstream owner even when no user is connected. Eval and optimizer lanes are registry-less development tools and therefore do not use dynamic model authentication.

entra_app is an explicit model-definition choice; Turnstone never changes a failed or ownerless entra_obo call into a client-credentials grant. An entra_obo call with no effective user always refuses. A dynamic alias without a real static key also always refuses instead of issuing its SDK-construction placeholder. When a real static key is explicitly configured, mint failures may use it by default; set model.auth_fail_closed = true to prohibit even that fallback. A refusal is not routed through the model fallback chain.

Dynamic token caches are encrypted in mcp_user_tokens, shared across nodes, and memoized on each host. Unlinking a user's OIDC identity purges their entra_obo rows and memo entries. entra_app rows belong to the shared __app__ identity and are not user-deprovisioned; after client-credential revocation, an already-minted app bearer remains usable until its recorded expiry.

obo_audience is literal and capped at 2048 characters. Environment-variable expansion is deliberately not applied, so the allow-list decision cannot vary by node or expand beyond the persisted boundary.

Responses output controls (per-model)

Models whose capability table declares Responses output controls expose two additional fields in the Models create/edit shelf:

Field Stored capability Values Effect
Output verbosity verbosity low, medium, high Controls answer length independently of reasoning effort.
Reasoning mode reasoning_mode standard, pro Selects standard or higher-compute Pro execution without changing the model ID.

An empty selection means provider default and omits the capability key. Known GPT-5.6 models inherit support from the built-in table without persisting redundant support flags. An OpenAI-compatible model pinned to the Responses API can opt in with the supports_verbosity and supports_pro_mode capability tiles. Chat Completions and non-Responses providers do not surface or submit these controls.

Removed settings: model.name and model.context_window have been removed from ConfigStore. Model names and context windows are now configured per-model in the Models tab. A startup warning is logged if these keys appear in config.toml.

Reasoning persistence (per-model)

Two boolean flags on model_definitions (migration 052) control how reasoning text round-trips per model:

Flag Default Effect
surface_persisted_reasoning True Surface stored reasoning text on /history payloads so a page reload re-renders the reasoning bubble. Storage of reasoning bytes is independent of this flag — they ride in provider_data regardless.
replay_reasoning_to_model False Send stored reasoning blocks back to the provider on subsequent turns. Capability-gated: only takes effect when the model's ModelCapabilities.supports_reasoning_replay is also True. Set on canonical OpenAI gpt-5*/o-series and Anthropic Claude entries; unknown / local-server models default to False so an operator who flips the flag on a model whose API doesn't understand reasoning replay silently no-ops rather than 400-ing.

Edit both via the admin Models tab. See the architecture doc for the provider-side mechanics (Anthropic thinking, OpenAI Responses reasoning + include=["reasoning.encrypted_content"], synthetic reasoning_text for Chat Completions / vLLM / llama.cpp / Gemini-compat).

Task agent overrides

task_agent sub-sessions resolve independently from the conversation model so operators can pick a cheaper/faster model for autonomous loops:

Setting Purpose
model.task_alias Alias used for task_agent sub-sessions. Falls back to [model].agent_model in config.toml, then the session's active model.
model.task_effort Reasoning effort for task_agent. Empty string means "inherit from the session".

Both are live-editable from the Settings tab and take effect on the next sub-agent invocation — no restart required.


Bootstrap vs ConfigStore

Bootstrap settings are required before storage is available (database connection, Redis, auth secrets, server bind address). These stay in config.toml and environment variables.

Category Section Where
API credentials [api] config.toml / env
Database [database] config.toml / env
Auth [auth] config.toml / env
Console bind [console] config.toml / env

ConfigStore settings are loaded from the database after storage initialization:

Section Settings
model default_alias, auth_audience_allowlist, auth_fail_closed, temperature, max_tokens, reasoning_effort, task_alias, task_effort
session instructions, retention_days, compact_max_tokens, auto_compact_pct
tools timeout, truncation, agent_max_turns, skip_permissions, search, search_threshold, search_max_results
server workstream_idle_timeout, max_workstreams
cluster node_fan_out_limit, mcp_max_servers
mcp config_path, registry_url
ratelimit enabled, requests_per_second, burst, trusted_proxies
health backend_probe_interval, backend_probe_timeout, circuit_breaker_threshold, circuit_breaker_cooldown
judge enabled, model, provider, base_url, api_key, confidence_threshold, max_context_ratio, timeout, read_only_tools, output_guard, redact_secrets, cancel_on_approval
interface close_tab_action, theme
skills discovery_url
memory relevance_k, fetch_limit, max_content, nudge_cooldown, nudges

Settings are addressed by dotted key (e.g. memory.relevance_k). Each has a declared type (int, float, str, bool), optional min_value/max_value range, optional choices list, and an is_secret flag.


Storage

The system_settings table (migration 015) stores settings as JSON-encoded values with a composite primary key of (key, node_id):

Column Type Description
key text Dotted setting key (e.g. model.temperature)
value text JSON-encoded value
node_id text Node ID for per-node overrides (empty string = global)
is_secret int 1 if the setting contains secrets
changed_by text Username of last editor
created text ISO timestamp
updated text ISO timestamp

Per-node overrides layer on top of global settings. When ConfigStore loads, it fetches global settings first, then overlays per-node values.


Admin API

Four endpoints on the console server, all requiring the admin.settings permission.

GET /v1/api/admin/settings

List all settings with their effective values, defaults, and metadata.

Response: 200

{
  "settings": [
    {
      "key": "model.temperature",
      "value": 0.7,
      "source": "storage",
      "type": "float",
      "description": "Sampling temperature",
      "section": "model",
      "is_secret": false,
      "node_id": "",
      "changed_by": "admin",
      "updated": "2026-03-14T10:00:00",
      "restart_required": false
    }
  ]
}

GET /v1/api/admin/settings/schema

Return the full registry catalog (all defined settings with metadata). Useful for building dynamic admin UIs.

Response: 200

{
  "schema": [
    {
      "key": "model.temperature",
      "type": "float",
      "default": 0.5,
      "description": "Sampling temperature",
      "section": "model",
      "is_secret": false,
      "min_value": 0.0,
      "max_value": 2.0,
      "choices": null,
      "restart_required": false
    }
  ]
}

PUT /v1/api/admin/settings/{key}

Update a setting. The value is validated against the registry (type coercion, range, choices). Secret settings (is_secret=true) cannot be written via the API -- they must be configured via config.toml or environment variables.

Path parameters:

Parameter Type Description
key string Dotted setting key (e.g. model.temperature)

Request body:

{
  "value": 0.7,
  "node_id": ""
}
Field Type Required Default Description
value any yes -- New value (type-coerced against registry)
node_id string no "" Node ID for per-node override

Response (success): 200

{
  "key": "model.temperature",
  "value": 0.7,
  "source": "storage",
  "type": "float",
  "description": "Sampling temperature",
  "section": "model",
  "is_secret": false,
  "node_id": "",
  "changed_by": "admin",
  "updated": "",
  "restart_required": false
}

Errors:

Status Condition
400 Unknown key, invalid value, type mismatch, out of range
403 Secret setting (must use config.toml or env)

DELETE /v1/api/admin/settings/{key}

Reset a setting to its registry default by removing it from storage.

Path parameters:

Parameter Type Description
key string Dotted setting key

Query parameters:

Parameter Type Required Default Description
node_id string no "" Node ID (empty = global)

Response (success): 200

{"status": "ok", "key": "model.temperature", "default": 0.5}

Response (not found): 404

{"error": "Setting 'model.temperature' has no stored value"}

Secret Settings

Settings with is_secret=True (currently only judge.api_key) are blocked from the write API with a 403 response. This prevents accidental exposure through the admin UI or audit logs. Secret settings must be configured via config.toml or environment variables.

The list endpoint masks secret values: stored secrets appear as "***" rather than their actual value.


Hot Reload

ConfigStore caches all settings in memory for fast, lock-free reads. To refresh the cache after external changes (e.g. direct database edits or cluster-wide propagation):

POST /v1/api/_internal/config-reload

This triggers ConfigStore.reload(), which re-reads all settings from storage and atomically swaps the cache. The version counter increments on every reload.

Behavior after reload:

  • New workstreams pick up updated values immediately (via session_factory)
  • Existing sessions keep their frozen configuration (settings are captured at workstream creation time, not read on every turn)
  • Settings marked restart_required=True need a server restart to take effect

Migration from config.toml

On startup, warn_migrated_settings() scans config.toml for keys that are now managed by ConfigStore. Each overlap produces a warning:

WARNING config.toml [model] temperature is now managed via Settings API —
this value will be ignored. Use the admin Settings tab or
PUT /v1/api/admin/settings/model.temperature to configure.

To migrate:

  1. Note the values from config.toml for sections that overlap with ConfigStore
  2. Use PUT /v1/api/admin/settings/{key} or the console Settings tab to set each value
  3. Remove the migrated sections from config.toml
  4. Restart the server to verify no warnings

SDK

Python

from turnstone.sdk import TurnstoneConsole

with TurnstoneConsole("http://localhost:9090", token="tok_xxx") as admin:
    # List all settings with effective values
    result = admin.list_settings()
    for s in result["settings"]:
        print(f"{s['key']} = {s['value']} (source: {s['source']})")

    # Get the schema catalog
    schema = admin.get_settings_schema()

    # Update a setting
    admin.update_setting("model.temperature", value=0.7)

    # Update with per-node override
    admin.update_setting("model.temperature", value=0.3, node_id="node-2")

    # Reset to default
    admin.delete_setting("model.temperature")

TypeScript

import { TurnstoneConsole } from "@turnstone/sdk";

const admin = new TurnstoneConsole({
  baseUrl: "http://localhost:9090",
  token: "tok_xxx",
});

// List all settings
const result = await admin.listSettings();
for (const s of result.settings) {
  console.log(`${s.key} = ${s.value} (source: ${s.source})`);
}

// Get schema catalog
const schema = await admin.getSettingsSchema();

// Update a setting
await admin.updateSetting("model.temperature", { value: 0.7 });

// Reset to default
await admin.deleteSetting("model.temperature");

Architecture

See Settings Architecture diagram for the full data flow covering server startup, admin API writes, hot reload, and settings precedence.