Files
openclaw/docs/tools/exec.md
T
Marvinthebored bd897a6143 fix(exec): make timeout unit explicit (#119874)
* fix: exec timeout field does not state its unit, so callers pass milliseconds

`exec.timeout` is in seconds, but its sibling `yieldMs` is in milliseconds and
the `process` tool's identically named `timeout` is also in milliseconds. Those
two tools are used together in one workflow: exec backgrounds a long command,
then process polls it.

The unit exists only in the field description, and code mode deliberately defers
descriptions - the model sees `timeout?: number` and nothing else. A caller that
guesses milliseconds passes 900000 intending 15 minutes and gets ~10 days, so
the command never times out.

Add `timeoutSeconds` as the canonical field, matching the convention already
used by the config default (`tools.exec.timeoutSeconds`) and the sibling
(`yieldMs`). Keep `timeout` as a deprecated alias; `timeoutSeconds` wins when
both are supplied. Project the new field onto `nodeExecSchema`, which
hand-picks its properties.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01XQojYRCUdXhcKFeu4QW5Gh

* fix(ci): satisfy test-type and dependency checks

Two CI failures from the test approach, not the change itself.

- check-test-types: TypeBox's TOptional does not surface `description` on its
  static type, so the schema assertions failed under tsgo. Read it through a
  narrow accessor instead.
- check-dependencies: knip flagged resolveExecTimeoutSeconds as an unused
  export because only the test imported it. Move it beside the schema it
  resolves, where the exec runtime imports it, so it is production-reachable.

Verified with the same commands CI runs: `run-tsgo.mjs -p
test/tsconfig/tsconfig.core.test.json` reports no errors in these files, and
knip --production reports no unused exports.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01XQojYRCUdXhcKFeu4QW5Gh

* fix(ci): fit the exec description budget and satisfy oxlint

- `agent-tools.schema.test.ts` enforces a 550-char budget on the exec tool's
  model-facing descriptions; the two new ones pushed it to 640. Shortened both.
  The rename is what makes this possible: the unit now lives in the field name,
  so the description no longer has to carry it. Extended that budget test to
  pin `timeoutSeconds` alongside `timeout`.
- oxlint `no-base-to-string`: the test's description accessor typed the field as
  `unknown` and stringified it. Typed as `string | undefined` instead.

Verified: budget test passes (137 tests green across both suites), and all six
behavior tests still fail against origin/main.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01XQojYRCUdXhcKFeu4QW5Gh

* fix: remove the unit-ambiguous exec timeout field instead of deprecating it

Owner decision on the review's "ambiguous model-visible alias" finding: drop
`timeout` entirely rather than keep it as a deprecated alias.

Keeping it visible defeated the purpose. Code mode renders property names and
types and defers descriptions, so a model would still be offered a bare
`timeout` sitting next to a millisecond-based `yieldMs` and could still pick it.
A deprecation marker in a description the model never sees changes nothing.

Backward compatibility is not required here: every tool call is constructed
fresh by the model from the current schema, and a repository search found no
internal caller passing `timeout` to the exec tool. `timeoutSeconds` is now the
only exec timeout field, on both the main and node-only surfaces.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01XQojYRCUdXhcKFeu4QW5Gh

* fix: migrate the internal exec callers to timeoutSeconds

Removing `timeout` from the exec schema broke three real internal callers that
the earlier survey missed, plus two test files and the runtime's own reads.
`check-test-types` caught it; my local search had filtered `timeout:` matches to
lines mentioning "exec" and discarded these.

- src/auto-reply/reply/bash-command.ts
- src/auto-reply/reply/commands-diagnostics.ts
- src/auto-reply/reply/commands-export-trajectory.ts
  all passed `timeout: timeoutSec` and now pass `timeoutSeconds: timeoutSec`.
- bash-tools.exec-run.ts reads the field through the same typeof narrowing the
  third call site already used; `params` is loosely typed, so a raw read is
  `unknown`.
- Test fixtures updated. A vitest `waitFor({ timeout })` option in
  background-abort.test.ts is NOT an exec param and was left alone.

`run-tsgo.mjs -p test/tsconfig/tsconfig.core.test.json` now reports zero errors
in changed files; the 5 remaining `rejectSymlinks` errors are pre-existing on
main. 148 tests pass across the affected suites.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01XQojYRCUdXhcKFeu4QW5Gh

* docs: synchronize the exec config table with timeoutSeconds

Addresses the P2 finding. The tools.exec.timeoutSeconds row still described the
per-call override as `timeout` and `timeout: 0`, which no longer exist. The
only remaining bare `timeout` reference in this page is the deliberate
contrast with the process tool's millisecond field.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01XQojYRCUdXhcKFeu4QW5Gh

* fix: migrate the QA lifecycle caller and the shared ExecToolArgs contract

Two findings from the re-review of 6e8c3560e7, both real.

[P1] test/e2e/qa-lab/runtime/openclaw-exec-process-lifecycle.e2e.test.ts:174
still passed `timeout: 0.05`. After the removal that field is accepted and
ignored, so the call silently used the default timeout and could not produce
the asserted 50 ms `overall-timeout` result. Migrated.

[P2] ExecToolArgs in bash-tools.exec-request-preparation.ts:33 still declared
`timeout?: number` while the runtime reads only `timeoutSeconds`, offering
request-preparation users an accepted-but-inert argument. Renamed.

Why the typecheck missed both: ExecToolArgs is
`Record<string, unknown> & {...}`, and that index signature defeats excess
property checking, so a stale member produces no error at any call site. The
e2e file also sits outside the core test tsconfig I had been running locally.

Left alone deliberately: `processTool.execute({ action: "poll", timeout })` is
milliseconds and correct, and `createBashTool` in sessions/tools/bash.ts is a
separate tool surface with its own timeout.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01XQojYRCUdXhcKFeu4QW5Gh

* fix(test): update the node exec tool property assertion to timeoutSeconds

src/gateway/tool-resolution.exclude.test.ts:413 asserts the exact property list
of the node-forced exec tool and still expected "timeout". Renamed to match
nodeExecSchema.

Found by checks-node-compact-large-5; my local core-test tsconfig does not cover
src/gateway, so it did not surface there.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01XQojYRCUdXhcKFeu4QW5Gh

* fix: accept the legacy exec timeout as an undocumented alias

Removing the field from the schema does not reject it at runtime: the exec
schema accepts unknown properties, so a call built against an older schema was
accepted and then silently ignored, taking the default deadline instead of the
one it asked for.

Route every read through resolveExecTimeoutSeconds, which prefers the canonical
timeoutSeconds and falls back to a numeric timeout. The alias stays out of
execSchema, nodeExecSchema and ExecToolArgs, so no new caller can adopt it.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01XQojYRCUdXhcKFeu4QW5Gh

* docs: update the background-process guide to timeoutSeconds

The exec parameter table and the inheritance note still taught `timeout` and
`timeout: 0`, which kept the retired spelling publicly discoverable and
contradicted the exec guide.

`poll`'s own millisecond `timeout` is left alone; it is a different tool and a
different unit, which is the collision this rename removes.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01XQojYRCUdXhcKFeu4QW5Gh

* fix(exec): reject removed timeout field

* chore: regenerate plugin SDK API baseline

---------

Co-authored-by: Marvinthebored <262704729+Marvinthebored@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-authored-by: Patrick Erichsen <patrick.a.erichsen@gmail.com>
2026-08-10 20:02:53 -07:00

21 KiB

summary, read_when, title
summary read_when title
Exec tool usage, stdin modes, and TTY support
Using or modifying the exec tool
Debugging stdin or TTY behavior
Exec tool

Run shell commands in the workspace. exec is a mutating shell surface: commands can create, edit, or delete files wherever the selected host or sandbox filesystem permits. Disabling OpenClaw filesystem tools such as write, edit, or apply_patch does not make exec read-only.

Supports foreground and background execution via process. If process is disallowed, exec runs synchronously and ignores yieldMs/background. Background sessions are scoped per agent; process only sees sessions from the same agent.

Parameters

Shell command to run. Working directory for the command. Key/value environment overrides merged on top of the inherited environment. Auto-background the command after this delay (ms). Background the command immediately instead of waiting for `yieldMs`. Override the configured exec timeout for this call, in **seconds**. Note the sibling `yieldMs` is in milliseconds, and the `process` tool's identically named `timeout` is also in milliseconds - pass `timeoutSeconds` so the unit is explicit at the call site. Applies to foreground, background, `yieldMs`, gateway, sandbox, and node `system.run` execution. `timeoutSeconds: 0` disables the exec process timeout for that call. Run in a pseudo-terminal when available. Use for TTY-only CLIs, coding agents, and terminal UIs. Where to execute. `auto` resolves to `sandbox` when a sandbox runtime is active and `gateway` otherwise. Ignored for normal tool calls. `gateway`/`node` security is derived from `tools.exec.mode` and the host approvals file; elevated mode can force full access only when the operator explicitly grants elevated access. The baseline ask mode is derived from `tools.exec.mode` and host approvals. For channel-origin model calls, per-call `ask` is ignored when the effective host ask is `off`; otherwise it can only harden to a stricter mode. Node id/name when `host=node`. Request elevated mode: escape the sandbox onto the configured host path. `security=full` is forced only when elevated resolves to `full`.

Notes:

  • host only accepts auto, sandbox, gateway, or node. It is not a hostname selector; hostname-like values are rejected before the command runs.
  • Per-call host=node is allowed from auto; per-call host=gateway is only allowed when no sandbox runtime is active.
  • With no extra config, host=auto still "just works": no sandbox means it resolves to gateway; a live sandbox means it stays in the sandbox.
  • elevated escapes the sandbox onto the configured host path: gateway by default, or node when tools.exec.host=node (or the session default is host=node). It is only available when elevated access is enabled for the current session/provider.
  • gateway/node approvals are controlled by the host approvals file.
  • node requires a paired node (companion app or headless node host). If multiple nodes are available, set exec.node or tools.exec.node to select one.
  • exec host=node is the only shell-execution path for nodes; the legacy nodes.run wrapper has been removed.
  • On non-Windows hosts, exec uses SHELL when set; if SHELL is fish, it prefers bash (or sh) from PATH to avoid fish-incompatible bashisms, then falls back to SHELL if neither exists.
  • On Windows hosts, exec prefers PowerShell 7 (pwsh) discovery (Program Files, ProgramW6432, then PATH), then falls back to Windows PowerShell 5.1.
  • On non-Windows gateway hosts, bash and zsh exec commands use a startup snapshot. OpenClaw captures sourceable aliases/functions and a small safe environment set from shell startup files into $OPENCLAW_STATE_DIR/cache/shell-snapshots/, then sources that snapshot before each exec command. Secret-looking variables are excluded; sandbox and node exec do not use this snapshot. Set OPENCLAW_EXEC_SHELL_SNAPSHOT=0 in the Gateway process environment to disable this snapshot path.
  • Host execution (gateway/node) rejects env.PATH and loader overrides (LD_*/DYLD_*) to prevent binary hijacking or injected code.
  • OpenClaw sets OPENCLAW_SHELL=exec in the spawned command environment (including PTY and sandbox execution) so shell/profile rules can detect exec-tool context.
  • For channel-origin runs, OpenClaw also exposes a narrow sender/chat identity JSON payload in OPENCLAW_CHANNEL_CONTEXT when the channel provided those ids.
  • exec cannot run openclaw channels login or /approve shell commands: openclaw channels login is an interactive channel-auth flow, and /approve needs to go through the approval command handler, not a shell. Run channel login in a terminal on the gateway host, or use a channel-specific login agent tool when one exists (for example whatsapp_login).
  • Important: sandboxing is off by default. If sandboxing is off, implicit host=auto resolves to gateway. Explicit host=sandbox still fails closed instead of silently running on the gateway host. Enable sandboxing or use host=gateway with approvals.
  • Script preflight checks (for common Python/Node shell-syntax mistakes) only inspect files inside the effective workdir boundary. If a script path resolves outside workdir, preflight is skipped for that file. Preflight also skips entirely when host=gateway and the effective policy is security=full with ask=off.
  • For long-running work that starts now, start it once and rely on automatic completion wake when it is enabled and the command emits output or fails. Use process for logs, status, input, or intervention; do not emulate scheduling with sleep loops, timeout loops, or repeated polling.
  • Agent-started background commands appear in the Web, iOS, and Android background-task views until they finish. The task ledger is finalized before the completion heartbeat wakes the agent again.
  • For work that should happen later or on a schedule, use cron instead of exec sleep/delay patterns.

Config

Key Default Notes
tools.exec.timeoutSeconds 1800 Default per-command exec timeout in seconds. Per-call timeoutSeconds overrides it; per-call timeoutSeconds: 0 disables the exec process timeout.
tools.exec.host auto Resolves to sandbox when a sandbox runtime is active, gateway otherwise.
tools.exec.mode host-derived Canonical policy knob. See Modes below.
tools.exec.reviewer.model configured agent primary Optional provider/model override for mode=auto review.
tools.exec.reviewer.timeoutMs 30000 Per-stage timeout for reviewer model preparation and completion before human fallback.
tools.exec.node unset
tools.exec.notifyOnExit true When true, backgrounded exec sessions enqueue a system event and request a heartbeat on exit.
tools.exec.approvalRunningNoticeMs 10000 Emit a single "running" notice when an approval-gated exec runs longer than this (0 disables).
tools.exec.strictInlineEval false See Inline eval.
tools.exec.commandHighlighting false When true, approval prompts can highlight parser-derived command spans in the command text. Set globally or per agent; does not change approval policy.
tools.exec.pathPrepend unset List of directories to prepend to PATH for exec runs (gateway + sandbox only).
tools.exec.safeBins unset Stdin-only safe binaries that can run without explicit allowlist entries. See Safe bins.
tools.exec.safeBinTrustedDirs /bin, /usr/bin Additional explicit directories trusted for safeBins path checks. PATH entries are never auto-trusted.
tools.exec.safeBinProfiles unset Optional custom argv policy per safe bin (minPositional, maxPositional, allowedValueFlags, deniedFlags).

No-approval host exec is the default for gateway and node (mode=full) — this comes from the host-policy defaults, not from host=auto. If you want approvals/allowlist behavior, set tools.exec.mode and tighten the host approvals file; see Exec approvals. To force gateway or node routing regardless of sandbox state, set tools.exec.host or use /exec host=....

Example:

{
  tools: {
    exec: {
      pathPrepend: ["~/bin", "/opt/oss/bin"],
    },
  },
}

Modes

tools.exec.mode is the canonical persisted policy knob. Runtime security and approval behavior are derived from it.

Mode security ask Behavior
deny deny off Exec is denied.
allowlist allowlist off Only allowlisted/safe-bin commands run; nothing else is asked.
ask allowlist on-miss Allowlist matches run directly; everything else asks a human.
auto allowlist on-miss Allowlist/safe-bin matches run directly; everything else routes through OpenClaw's native auto reviewer before asking a human.
full full off No approval gate.

Per-session /exec ask=always still asks a human every time regardless of the persisted mode.

Auto-review approval is single-use. On the gateway, OpenClaw supplies the resolved executable path to the reviewer and pins execution to that same path. Commands that cannot be reduced to one enforceable execution plan—such as heredocs, shell expansions, or unsupported wrapper quoting—fall back to human approval even if the model would otherwise allow them.

Codex app-server command approvals that are not already decided by explicit runtime or native policy use the human approval route. OpenClaw does not run its configured exec reviewer for these requests because Codex does not expose an enforceable resolved executable that can bind the review decision to the command Codex runs.

Inline eval (strictInlineEval)

When tools.exec.strictInlineEval is true, inline interpreter-eval forms require reviewer or explicit approval: python -c, node -e, ruby -e, perl -e, php -r, lua -e, osascript -e, and similar forms across other supported interpreters and command carriers (awk, find -exec, make, sed, xargs, and more). In mode=auto, the normal exec approval path may let the native auto reviewer allow a clearly low-risk one-off command; direct node-host system.run calls still require an explicit approval because they cannot hand the command to a human approval route. If the reviewer asks, the request goes to a human. allow-always can still persist benign interpreter/script invocations, but inline-eval forms do not become durable allow rules.

PATH handling

  • host=gateway: merges your login-shell PATH into the exec environment. env.PATH overrides are rejected for host execution. The daemon itself still runs with a minimal PATH:
    • macOS: /opt/homebrew/bin, /usr/local/bin, /usr/bin, /bin
    • Linux: /usr/local/bin, /usr/bin, /bin
    • To prevent user shell configuration (like ~/.zshenv or /etc/zshenv) from overriding priority paths during startup, tools.exec.pathPrepend entries are securely prepended to the final PATH inside the shell command right before execution.
  • host=sandbox: runs sh -lc (login shell) inside the container, so /etc/profile may reset PATH. OpenClaw prepends env.PATH after profile sourcing via an internal env var (no shell interpolation); tools.exec.pathPrepend applies here too.
  • host=node: only non-blocked env overrides you pass are sent to the node. env.PATH overrides are rejected for host execution and ignored by node hosts. If you need additional PATH entries on a node, configure the node host service environment (systemd/launchd) or install tools in standard locations.

Per-agent node binding (use the keyed agent ID in config):

openclaw config get agents.entries
openclaw config set 'agents.entries.main.tools.exec.node' "node-id-or-name"

Control UI: the Devices page includes a small "Exec node binding" panel for the same settings.

Session overrides (/exec)

Use /exec to set per-session defaults for host, security, ask, and node. Send /exec with no arguments to show the current values.

Example:

/exec host=auto security=allowlist ask=on-miss node=mac-1

/exec is only honored for authorized senders through channel allowlists/pairing and access groups. Access-group enforcement is always on. It updates session state only and does not write config. Authorized external channel senders may set these session defaults. Internal gateway/webchat clients need operator.admin to persist them.

To hard-disable exec, deny it via tool policy (tools.deny: ["exec"] or per-agent). Host approvals still apply unless you explicitly set security=full and ask=off.

Exec approvals (companion app / node host)

Sandboxed agents can require per-request approval before exec runs on the gateway or node host. See Exec approvals for the policy, allowlist, and UI flow.

When a human approval is required, node-host and non-native gateway flows return immediately with status: "approval-pending" and an approval id. Native chat and Web UI gateway flows can instead wait inline and return the final command result after approval. An approval-pending result means the command has not started, so foreground fallback warnings appear only if the approved command actually runs inline. Approved asynchronous runs emit command progress and completion system events (Exec running / Exec finished); denied or timed-out approvals are terminal and do not wake the agent session with a denial system event.

On channels with native approval cards/buttons, the agent should rely on that native UI first and only include a manual /approve command when the tool result explicitly says chat approvals are unavailable or manual approval is the only path.

Allowlist + safe bins

Manual allowlist enforcement matches resolved binary path globs and bare command-name globs. Bare names match only commands invoked through PATH, so rg can match /opt/homebrew/bin/rg when the command is rg, but not ./rg or /tmp/rg.

When security=allowlist, shell commands are auto-allowed only if every pipeline segment is allowlisted or a safe bin. Chaining (;, &&, ||) and redirections are rejected in allowlist mode unless every top-level segment satisfies the allowlist (including safe bins). Redirections remain unsupported. Durable allow-always trust does not bypass that rule: a chained command still requires every top-level segment to match.

autoAllowSkills is a separate convenience path in exec approvals, not the same as manual path allowlist entries. For strict explicit trust, keep autoAllowSkills disabled.

Use the two controls for different jobs:

  • tools.exec.safeBins: small, stdin-only stream filters.
  • tools.exec.safeBinTrustedDirs: explicit extra trusted directories for safe-bin executable paths.
  • tools.exec.safeBinProfiles: explicit argv policy for custom safe bins.
  • allowlist: explicit trust for executable paths.

Do not treat safeBins as a generic allowlist, and do not add interpreter/runtime binaries (for example python3, node, ruby, bash). If you need those, use explicit allowlist entries and keep approval prompts enabled.

openclaw security audit warns when interpreter/runtime safeBins entries are missing explicit profiles, and openclaw doctor --fix can scaffold missing custom safeBinProfiles entries. openclaw security audit and openclaw doctor also warn when you explicitly add broad-behavior bins such as jq back into safeBins (jq can read environment data and load jq code from modules or startup files, so prefer explicit allowlist entries or approval-gated runs instead). jq is denied as a safe bin even when it is explicitly listed. If you explicitly allowlist interpreters, enable tools.exec.strictInlineEval so inline code-eval forms still require reviewer or explicit approval.

For full policy details and examples, see Exec approvals and Safe bins versus allowlist.

Examples

Foreground:

{ "tool": "exec", "command": "ls -la" }

Background + poll:

{"tool":"exec","command":"npm run build","yieldMs":1000}
{"tool":"process","action":"poll","sessionId":"<id>"}

Polling is for on-demand status, not waiting loops. If automatic completion wake is enabled, the command can wake the session when it emits output or fails.

Send keys (tmux-style):

{"tool":"process","action":"send-keys","sessionId":"<id>","keys":["Enter"]}
{"tool":"process","action":"send-keys","sessionId":"<id>","keys":["C-c"]}
{"tool":"process","action":"send-keys","sessionId":"<id>","keys":["Up","Up","Enter"]}

Submit (send CR only):

{ "tool": "process", "action": "submit", "sessionId": "<id>" }

Paste (bracketed by default):

{ "tool": "process", "action": "paste", "sessionId": "<id>", "text": "line1\nline2\n" }

apply_patch

apply_patch is a subtool of exec for structured multi-file edits. It is enabled by default and available to any model provider; allowModels can restrict it. Use config only when you want to disable it or restrict it to specific models:

{
  tools: {
    exec: {
      applyPatch: { workspaceOnly: true, allowModels: ["gpt-5.6-sol"] },
    },
  },
}

Notes:

  • Tool policy still applies; allow: ["write"] implicitly allows apply_patch.
  • deny: ["write"] does not deny apply_patch; deny apply_patch explicitly or use deny: ["group:fs"] when patch writes should also be blocked.
  • Config lives under tools.exec.applyPatch.
  • tools.exec.applyPatch.enabled defaults to true; set it to false to disable the tool.
  • tools.exec.applyPatch.workspaceOnly defaults to true (workspace-contained). Set it to false only if you intentionally want apply_patch to write/delete outside the workspace directory.
  • tools.exec.applyPatch.allowModels is an optional allowlist of model ids (raw, like gpt-5.4, or full, like openai/gpt-5.4). When set, only matching models get the tool; when unset, all models get it.