* refactor(gateway): remove reverse worker tunnel * test(gateway): align worker transport expectations * docs(gateway): clarify cloud worker ingress
32 KiB
summary, title, sidebarTitle, read_when, status, doc-schema-version
| summary | title | sidebarTitle | read_when | status | doc-schema-version |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dispatch session work to throwaway cloud machines with OpenClaw worker turns or Codex remote execution | Cloud Workers | Cloud Workers | You want agent session work to run on ephemeral cloud machines, or you are configuring cloudWorkers profiles. | active | 1 |
Cloud workers move a session's coding work onto a throwaway cloud machine while the session stays visible in the sidebar and its transcript remains owned by the Gateway. The bundled Crabbox provider boots the box, runs profile setup, and starts openclaw connect --ephemeral. The enrolled node then receives the Gateway's pinned worker bundle and hosts the same restricted openclaw worker children as any paired session-capable device.
Enrollment is environment-owned and replay-safe. The Gateway persists one setup identity before provider allocation, binds the first authenticated device identity to that exact environment, and reuses the durable device token when provisioning resumes. Initial enrollment and replay both enable worker hosting only for that node process; they do not change durable worker-host configuration. Reclaim or destroy releases the cloud lease and removes the environment-owned node pairing.
When the work is done (or the box dies), the machine is discarded. The durable state — transcript, last-reconciled workspace files, and placement records — lives with the Gateway.
Cloud workers are opt-in. Until you configure a profile, clients hide the Cloud destination and the Gateway does not advertise `sessions.dispatch`. The `cloudWorkers` config schema and the read-only `environments.list` and `environments.status` methods remain available for configuration and environment discovery.What runs where
| Concern | OpenClaw worker-turn mode |
Codex remote-exec mode |
|---|---|---|
| Agent runtime and turn loop | Cloud box (openclaw worker) |
Gateway (Codex app-server) |
| Command, filesystem, and HTTP work | Cloud box | SSH-backed provider sandbox |
| Model inference and provider auth | Gateway, proxied by {provider, model} reference |
Gateway, including ChatGPT subscription or API-key auth |
| Transcript and live session state | Gateway, fed by the worker's replayable event stream | Gateway through the normal local harness path |
| Workspace file state | Changed on the box; reconciled by the Gateway | Changed remotely; reconciled by the Gateway |
The bundled Crabbox provider supports worker-turn through the node transport. Codex remote-exec remains available only with a provider that explicitly supports its SSH sandbox carrier; OpenClaw rejects a node-only profile before allocating a lease.
After Crabbox setup, the cloud node dials the Gateway's public TLS endpoint over outbound WebSocket. Worker control and workspace transfer use the authenticated node and worker channels, not a Gateway-created reverse tunnel or rsync. Crabbox itself may still require SSH reachability while its CLI runs the provider-owned setup command. Outbound internet access is provider policy; the default AWS profile can reach the internet unless you restrict its network or security group.
Requirements
- A worker provider plugin. The bundled
crabboxplugin drives the Crabbox CLI, which brokers leases across cloud backends (AWS, Hetzner, and others). Install Crabbox 0.41.1 or newer for the operating-system user that runs the Gateway and put it on that user'sPATH, or setsettings.binaryto its absolute path. Keeping placed workers alive also requires a release that includescrabbox heartbeat(added after v0.43.0). Versions through 0.43.0 can allocate fixed-ID worker leases but lack heartbeat support; OpenClaw continues operating with one warning, and the coordinator may reap a placed worker after itsidleTimeout. - For Crabbox AWS workers, the effective
aws.instanceProfilemust be empty. The provider checkscrabbox config show --jsonbefore allocation, then requirescrabbox inspect --jsonto reportproviderMetadata.instanceProfileAttached: falsefrom EC2DescribeInstances. Leases with an instance role or without authoritative metadata are stopped and rejected. - Node.js on the leased machine. Bare cloud images usually lack it — install it in the profile's
setupcommand. - A live, registry-owned session managed worktree (create one with
worktree: true). Cloud dispatch does not accept an arbitrary plain directory. After dispatch admission, the workspace transport may use manifest mirroring if Git metadata later becomes unavailable; this transport behavior does not make plain directories dispatchable.
Coordinator-backed Crabbox
In managed mode, the Crabbox coordinator owns the cloud-provider credentials and provisions AWS on the Gateway user's behalf. Local AWS keys are not required. Authenticate interactively, then verify the stored coordinator and provider state:
Crabbox normally discovers the Gateway host's outbound IPv4 when a lease is requested and sends that /32 as the effective SSH ingress policy. This discovered value is request-scoped, so crabbox config show --json can legitimately continue to show an empty aws.sshCIDRs list.
For a fixed ingress policy, determine the outbound IPv4 yourself:
curl -fsS https://checkip.amazonaws.com
Then add that address as a /32 to Crabbox's own configuration. For example, if the command prints 203.0.113.10:
aws:
sshCIDRs:
- 203.0.113.10/32
Crabbox setup transport originates from the Gateway host, while the coordinator API may see a reverse-proxy or request-source address. Explicit pinning is useful when outbound detection is unavailable or a fixed policy is required.
crabbox login --url <coordinator-url> --provider aws
crabbox config show --json
crabbox whoami --json
crabbox doctor --provider aws --json
Before provisioning, review crabbox doctor --provider aws --json for provider-readiness failures. If aws.sshCIDRs is explicitly configured, also confirm crabbox config show --json reports the expected /32; an empty list is valid when using request-time discovery. doctor is non-mutating: it checks the coordinator, broker identity, local tools, and read-only AWS control-plane access without creating or changing a lease. It cannot prove mutating IAM permissions such as key-pair import, instance launch, tagging, or termination; a direct-provider report containing mutation=false is not a write-access attestation. Trusted automation can pipe an approved coordinator token through stdin instead of placing it on the command line:
printf '%s' "$CRABBOX_COORDINATOR_TOKEN" | crabbox login \
--url <coordinator-url> \
--provider aws \
--token-stdin
Keep the token out of repository config and shell arguments.
Configuration
Add a profile under cloudWorkers.profiles in openclaw.json:
{
"cloudWorkers": {
"profiles": {
"aws": {
"provider": "crabbox",
"install": "bundle",
"settings": {
"provider": "aws",
"class": "standard",
"ttl": "8h",
"idleTimeout": "45m",
"setup": "test -x /usr/bin/node || (curl -fsSL https://deb.nodesource.com/setup_22.x | sudo -E bash - && sudo apt-get install -y nodejs)"
}
}
}
}
}
Profile fields:
| Key | Meaning |
|---|---|
provider |
Worker provider id registered by a plugin (crabbox for the bundled plugin). |
install |
Installation preference for SSH-backed providers. The bundled Crabbox provider always installs the current Gateway bundle through the authenticated node channel. |
settings |
Provider-owned JSON. For crabbox: provider (backend), class (machine class), ttl, idleTimeout (Go durations), optional idempotent setup, and absolute binary path. While a session remains placed, OpenClaw heartbeats its lease at a safe fraction of idleTimeout; teardown stops the heartbeat before releasing the machine. Crabbox desktop profiles are not supported by the node transport. |
The enrolled node stores its identity, durable device token, endpoint, worker bundles, and workspaces under an isolated per-lease state directory on the disposable box. Provision replay first adopts the fixed Crabbox lease, then either resumes that node state or reuses the still-pending setup credential. It never mints a second environment identity for the same operation.
OpenClaw derives one canonical cbx_... lease ID from the durable provision operation and passes it to crabbox warmup --lease-id; the deterministic slug is display metadata only. If warmup commits but its response is lost, Gateway reconciliation repeats the same fixed-ID operation and Crabbox returns or adopts only the exactly attested lease. Intent drift, terminal ID reuse, and ambiguous unverified resources fail closed without allocating a replacement. A legacy dispatch interrupted before OpenClaw recorded a lease ID cannot be identified safely and fails visibly instead of falling back to slug adoption.
The setup command
settings.setup runs on the leased box after Crabbox reports it ready and before ephemeral node enrollment. It runs on every provision attempt, including replay after an interrupted dispatch, so it must be idempotent — guard installs with a command -v/test -x check as in the example. At minimum, the resulting machine needs Node.js and npx. If setup or enrollment fails, the provider stops the lease and the dispatch fails closed; no half-configured paid box is hidden behind terminal state.
Bundle installation
The setup bootstrap first reuses an installed openclaw binary when its version exactly matches the Gateway, then tries the exact openclaw@<version> registry package. For an unreleased source build, install a locally packed candidate with the same version in settings.setup; the provider will select it before touching the registry. After the node connects and publishes its session-host inventory, the Gateway pushes one content-addressed worker bundle through the paired channel. The node verifies and publishes those exact bytes without installing the normal OpenClaw package dependency tree. A stale Gateway build retires the environment and reprovisions against the current bundle rather than downgrading the execution-context protocol.
Verify the profile
Validate before restarting the Gateway:
openclaw config validate --json
openclaw plugins inspect crabbox --runtime --json
Changes under cloudWorkers.profiles require a Gateway restart. The default gateway.reload.mode: "hybrid" watches the config and performs that restart automatically; with reload watching disabled, run openclaw gateway restart.
After the Gateway is back, prove the profile is advertised and compare it with Crabbox's read-only lease inventory:
openclaw gateway call environments.list --params '{}'
crabbox list --provider aws --json
The environments.list response must include the configured id under profiles. crabbox list is non-mutating. By contrast, crabbox warmup provisions a lease, and crabbox stop or crabbox release tears one down; use those mutating commands only when you intend to create or destroy cloud resources.
Dispatching a session
In the Control UI, open New Session and use the unified Place picker to choose both the working folder and a Cloud · profile destination. A cloud destination appears only when all four eligibility gates pass:
- The connected operator has
operator.adminscope. environments.listadvertises at least one configured profile.- The selected Gateway folder is a Git checkout that can use a managed worktree.
- The selected agent runtime advertises cloud placement support.
Cloud selection enables that worktree automatically. The Gateway creates the session, finishes dispatch, and only then sends the first turn. The server badge in the session sidebar shows the durable placement state.
While a placement is active, OpenClaw automatically samples available space on the remote workspace volume. Low-space warnings appear in the selected chat and on the session's cloud badge. They are advisory, clear automatically after space recovers, and do not stop or reclaim the worker.
Runtime support
- OpenClaw uses
worker-turnplacement. The restrictedopenclaw workerprocess runs each turn on the leased node and proxies inference through the Gateway. - Codex uses
remote-execplacement only when the selected provider advertises an SSH-backed execution carrier. The bundled Crabbox node provider does not, so Codex dispatch to Crabbox fails before allocation.
Other runtimes remain unavailable unless their harness explicitly declares a cloud placement mode. Cloud targets are not offered for external CLI session catalogs. Remote-exec fails closed if the selected provider or placement sandbox is unavailable; it never falls back to running the operation on the Gateway host.
The equivalent RPC flow is:
Create a session with a managed worktree, then dispatch it. The RPC requires operator.admin and is advertised only while at least one worker profile is configured:
openclaw gateway call sessions.create \
--params '{"key":"agent:main:big-refactor","worktree":true,"cwd":"/path/to/repo","worktreeName":"big-refactor"}'
openclaw gateway call sessions.dispatch \
--timeout 1500000 \
--params '{"key":"agent:main:big-refactor","profileId":"aws"}'
Choose a machine class per session
A worker profile's settings.class remains its default. To choose a different size for one new placement, pass machineClass with profileId:
openclaw gateway call sessions.dispatch \
--timeout 1500000 \
--params '{"key":"agent:main:big-refactor","profileId":"aws","machineClass":"large"}'
The bundled Crabbox provider advertises standard (small repos and smoke checks), fast (general testing), large (broad test shards or heavy builds), and beast (high-core runs) through environments.list. You can also pass a provider-native server or instance type such as c7a.24xlarge; Crabbox treats any other non-empty class as that exact type. The selected value is fixed for that placement and reused by safe provisioning retries. machineClass is valid only with profileId, not deviceId.
sessions.dispatch closes local turn admission, drains active work, validates the eligible Git workspace inventory, provisions the lease, runs setup, enrolls the node, pushes the Gateway bundle, syncs the workspace, and returns once the placement reaches active ownership. Inventory validation happens before provider allocation and reports an invalid request with an actionable size or entry limit when the workspace cannot be dispatched. Budget several minutes for the first dispatch; leases and content-addressed bundles are reused where safe. After that, talk to the session as usual. OpenClaw turns route to the worker process; supported SSH-backed providers may still carry Codex remote-exec.
Completed cloud turns reconcile eligible, size-bounded workspace files back into the session's managed worktree before the turn claim is released. Worker-turn uses its terminal worker event to create the durable pending-result fence. Remote-exec waits for workspace quiescence and enters the same reconciliation flow after the local Codex attempt. Before applying the result, the Gateway stages complete authenticated base/current manifests plus each changed resulting blob as a Git ref under refs/openclaw/worker-results/; deletions are represented by the manifests and need no blob. This keeps the cloud delta recoverable even if the Gateway stops during the apply without duplicating unchanged baseline content. Workspace results use Git file semantics: regular files, executable bits, symlinks, additions, changes, and deletions are retained, while empty directories and other directory modes are not. The resulting file changes remain in the managed worktree for normal review and commit.
Apply uses the dispatch-time manifest as the merge base. Cloud-only changes are applied, local-only changes stay in place, and paths changed on both sides use a three-way keep-local policy. A conflicted turn still finishes: the transcript reports the bounded path summary and staged result ref, the placement exposes the same conflict for the Control UI, and non-conflicting cloud changes remain applied. The notice includes git show <ref>:<path> to inspect a present cloud file and a top-level literal-pathspec git checkout <ref> -- <path> command to take it from any workspace directory. Run the commands in Bash or zsh (Git Bash on Windows). If inspect says the path does not exist, the cloud result deleted it; verify and remove the retained local path manually. If checkout reports a file/directory obstruction, move or remove the blocking local path and retry. If the staged ref itself is gone, treat the notice as stale and do not change the local path. Conflicted staged refs remain available after the normal turn fence is released; a later clean result clears the notice and retires the old ref, while explicit fence removal is the final cleanup boundary.
While a fenced result is still reconciling, a new turn waits up to 15 seconds for the prior claim to release. If it is still busy, the turn fails with an actionable “previous cloud turn's workspace result is still reconciling” message and can be retried shortly. On restart, recovery discovers pending and staged results before stale-claim cleanup, completes or retries their local apply, and reclaims dead environments only after preserving the result. The bounded SQLite rollback journal makes an interrupted filesystem apply recoverable without replaying already accepted mutations.
To continue the same session somewhere else, open the Runs on Cloud chip and choose Move session…. Select the Gateway, a paired device, or a configured cloud profile and, when available, its machine class. Moving to the current profile with a different class resizes the session by replacing its worker. The Gateway closes new admission, interrupts any active turn, reconciles the source workspace, destroys the old environment, and then activates the destination. An interrupted turn is never replayed: partial output may disappear, and you send the next turn again after the move. The exact target, including a machine override, and bounded errors are durable, so the Control UI shows Moving to… or the recovery error after a reconnect, and Gateway restart recovery resumes the same operation before generic placement cleanup.
When the work is complete and no turn is running, choose Stop cloud worker… from the same chip. The Gateway performs one final workspace reconciliation before it destroys the environment. A placement already in draining or reconciling is finishing teardown; wait for its badge to become reclaimed before deleting the session.
Archiving a non-main cloud-worker session with an active placement also performs this safe stop and reclaim before the Gateway records it as archived. If the placement is still transitioning or failed without proof that its environment is gone, the session remains unarchived; wait for the placement to settle, then retry. Restoring the session retains the reclaimed placement metadata so the next turn can dispatch a fresh worker with the same workspace profile.
For a broken or runaway cloud environment, an operator can call environments.destroy with { "force": true } as a last resort. Forced teardown durably marks the placement failed and abandons any unreconciled remote result before destroying the environment.
The equivalent administrative RPC is:
openclaw gateway call sessions.reclaim \
--timeout 600000 \
--params '{"key":"agent:main:big-refactor"}'
The result placement is reclaimed after an active worker is safely stopped. If an earlier failure already proved that the environment is gone, reclaim clears the failed placement and returns local instead. No other placement states are successful reclaim results.
For automation, read the active placement's generation, environmentId, and activeOwnerEpoch from sessions.describe, then supply those exact source facts to sessions.move:
openclaw gateway call sessions.move \
--timeout 1500000 \
--params '{"key":"agent:main:big-refactor","expected":{"generation":5,"environmentId":"worker:source","ownerEpoch":2},"target":{"kind":"gateway"}}'
Worker targets use {"kind":"profile","profileId":"aws","machineClass":"fast"} or {"kind":"device","deviceId":"paired-device-id"}. Omit machineClass to use the profile default. Moving to the same profile with a different class is the resize workflow. A stale source is rejected rather than moving a newer placement. Successful results end in local for the Gateway target or active for a worker target.
Placement moves through a durable state machine (local → requested → provisioning → syncing → starting → active), so a Gateway restart mid-dispatch reconciles instead of leaking machines. A failed model turn keeps the active placement available for a retry. Workspace path conflicts keep the local version, apply the rest of the cloud result, and preserve the staged cloud ref for inspection; other reconciliation or lifecycle failures retain their durable recovery fence and diagnostic tail until recovery can safely retry or reclaim the environment.
What survives a dead machine
The Gateway owns the canonical session transcript in both modes. Worker-turn commits each complete user, assistant, and tool-result message before the worker's session write settles; remote-exec uses the normal local harness transcript path because the Codex app-server stays on the Gateway. If the machine disappears mid-message, durable history ends at the last committed message. Partial text or tool progress already shown by the live stream may disappear; the failed turn remains visible, and the failed placement records a bounded terminal reason above the composer.
Workspace state has a wider loss window. A completed turn reconciles cloud files before releasing its claim, and Stop cloud worker… performs one final reconciliation before destroying the machine. Changes made between reconciliations exist only on the box and can be lost. Session deletion does not synchronize an active placement: it must first be stopped or archived. Deletion then snapshots the already-reconciled managed worktree under refs/openclaw/snapshots/ before removing it.
After a failed placement, redispatch the session and retry the turn. A reclaimed placement redispatches automatically on the next turn. The next turn rebuilds model context from the Gateway transcript, so it continues from the messages that crossed the durability boundary.
Desktop
The bundled Crabbox provider does not support Cloud Worker Desktop after node transport convergence. Crabbox profiles with settings.desktop: true are rejected before allocation. Interactive desktop support requires a provider with a separate supported desktop carrier.
Security model
- Closed worker ingress. In worker-turn mode, the enrolled node launches the worker child, which dials the Gateway's authenticated public worker route and speaks a dedicated protocol with a closed method allowlist — a worker cannot call operator RPCs.
- Gateway-owned tool authority. In worker-turn mode, the Gateway projects current profile, provider, agent, group, sender, sandbox, delegation, inherited, and runtime-cap policy over the worker's fixed coding-tool catalog before every turn. The launch envelope carries only that final closed-vocabulary subset. Explicitly capped scheduled turns reuse their trusted owner-group context without sending that identity to the box or reapplying a fresh sender overlay. Tools outside the worker catalog remain unavailable; an empty result runs with no tools.
- Minted credentials, hashed at rest. Each dispatch mints a worker credential; the Gateway stores only its hash. Credential rotation and owner-epoch fencing guarantee at most one live owner per session — a stale worker that reconnects is fenced, never merged.
- Environment-bound enrollment. One short-lived node-only setup credential is bound to the durable environment before allocation. Its first authenticated Ed25519 device identity is recorded atomically with setup completion; replay cannot substitute an unrelated node.
- No standing model, forge, or cloud credentials on the box. OpenClaw worker turns proxy inference by
{provider, model}reference. Codex remote-exec keeps the app-server plus ChatGPT subscription or API-key auth on the Gateway and sends only sandbox operations to the box. Remote-exec requires prepared auth and rejects ambient auth fallback. Workspace git commits are authored without forge credentials, and Crabbox AWS lease metadata is checked authoritatively for an instance role before setup. Keep setup commands credential-free too. - Provider-owned egress. Gateway-proxied inference removes any OpenClaw need for direct model access, but OpenClaw does not rewrite provider firewalls. Restrict outbound traffic in the worker provider when the task requires it.
- Durable, exactly-once worker transcripts. In worker-turn mode, the worker commits transcript batches through a compare-and-swap protocol against the session's leaf; a stale base fail-stops the run instead of duplicating or rebasing paid output. Remote-exec writes through the Gateway's normal local harness path.
Troubleshooting
- No cloud profile is advertised — run
openclaw gateway call environments.list --params '{}'as an admin. If the response has noprofiles, validatecloudWorkers.profiles, inspect the provider plugin, and restart the Gateway. This is a configuration or provider-activation problem, not an authorization result. - Cloud destinations are hidden or an RPC is denied — the connected operator lacks
operator.admin. Reconnect with admin scope; configuring a profile does not grant that scope. - The selected runtime lacks cloud placement support — choose a model whose advertised runtime supports cloud placement. The bundled OpenClaw and Codex runtimes are supported; undeclared runtimes remain local-only.
- "Worker bootstrap requires Node.js on the leased host" — add a Node install to
settings.setup(see above). - AWS instance-role attestation fails — clear
aws.instanceProfile(andCRABBOX_AWS_INSTANCE_PROFILE, if set). Install Crabbox 0.41.1 or newer; older binaries do not satisfy the fixed-ID and authoritativeproviderMetadata.instanceProfileAttachedcontracts required for AWS admission. - Dispatch or workspace recovery fails — inspect
environments.listandsessions.describe. A failed environment exposes its bounded environment error. A failed placement exposesrecoveryErrorplus its durable per-sessionterminalReason; the selected Control UI chat shows that terminal reason above the composer. When deeper diagnosis is necessary, an operator on the Gateway host can inspect the durable worker state read-only. Do not edit the state database to bypass lifecycle fencing. - Crabbox setup cannot reach the lease — compare the Gateway host's current outbound IPv4 with an explicitly configured
aws.sshCIDRspolicy incrabbox config show --json. If the matching/32is absent, correct Crabbox's configuration and reruncrabbox doctor --provider aws --jsonbefore retrying. An empty configured list is valid when Crabbox discovers and injects the caller's/32for the request. - Node enrollment times out — verify the profile setup installed Node.js and
npx, the box can reach the Gateway's advertised TLS URL, and the Gateway's public worker/node WebSocket route is reachable. Inspect the per-lease node log on the box through Crabbox before releasing the failed lease. - Client timeout while dispatching —
openclaw gateway calldefaults to a 10s timeout; pass--timeoutgenerously. Dispatch keeps running server-side either way, and an identical retry on the same Gateway joins that in-flight operation instead of provisioning another worker. A retry with a different profile or session identity is rejected. - Direct AWS authorization fails after
doctorpasses —doctorproves read-only AWS access, not the complete mutation policy. Inspect the named denied action and grant only Crabbox's required provisioning/cleanup actions, or configure coordinator-backed Crabbox instead. A fresh direct AWS lease normally needs key-pair import beforeRunInstances; an authorization failure there creates no instance. - Worker reclaimed after upgrading from a 2026.7.2 beta — those betas used the older worker launch contract. On restart, OpenClaw destroys an idle incompatible worker, keeps the session and workspace, marks the placement reclaimed, and provisions a current worker on the next dispatch or turn. A beta worker interrupted while still starting is marked failed after cleanup; retry the dispatch to provision it with the current contract.
- Cloud workspace conflict notice — the turn completed and kept the local version of each listed path. Use the staged-ref commands in the notice to inspect or take the cloud version; no retry is required for the non-conflicting changes, which are already applied.
- Cloud session disk-space warning — delete unneeded files from the remote workspace or stop the cloud worker before large writes. The warning clears automatically after the next successful sample shows enough free space; a failed sample leaves the last successful warning visible and does not affect the session lifecycle.
- “The previous cloud turn's workspace result is still reconciling” — the Gateway waited briefly for the prior result's durable fence and could not acquire the session claim. Wait for reconciliation to finish, then retry the turn; restarting the Gateway is safe because recovery preserves staged results before reclaiming a dead worker.
- Lease housekeeping —
crabbox list --provider <backend> --jsonis a read-only inventory.crabbox stop --provider <backend> --id <lease>andcrabbox release --provider <backend> --id <lease>are destructive and release a lease manually. OpenClaw keeps the lease alive while its session is placed, then stops heartbeating during teardown so genuinely idle leases expire on the profile'sidleTimeout. Crabbox 0.43.0 and older do not expose the heartbeat command; OpenClaw warns once per environment and cannot prevent coordinator-idle reaping on those binaries.
Related
- Sandboxing — reducing blast radius for local tool execution
- Sessions CLI — inspecting stored sessions
- Configuration reference