* feat(channels): batch 3 producers drop media placeholder bodies
Media-placeholder program batch 3: iMessage, Signal, and WhatsApp stop
minting <media:kind> placeholder bodies. Primary bodies carry captions
only with one aligned structured fact per native attachment (type-only
for missing/rejected/oversized). Echo, quote, and pending-history
records gain structured media facts so dedupe and previews work without
rendered text. Signal media-only outbound sends drop the placeholder
body entirely (signal-cli accepts attachment-only sends; recipients now
see just the media). WhatsApp audio preflight de-stringed; qa-lab
sticker recognizer moved to structured facts; WhatsApp gif maps to
video (presentation mode, no behavioral consumer).
* test(whatsapp): keep media classifier private
Append imsg's own status message (SIP / library validation / macOS 26 AMFI gate)
to iMessage private-API blocked-action errors so operators see the real blocker
instead of a generic "run imsg launch". Add a dedicated 150s default timeout for
iMessage send RPCs (explicit opts and probeTimeoutMs still win) so macOS 26
bridge stalls are not aborted mid-send.
Staged mitigation: the longer wait fully activates once the companion bridge
timeout (openclaw/imsg#139) ships; on current imsg the bridge still returns at
its own 10s, so there is no regression. Diagnostics half is live-proven; the
delayed-send timeout is covered by source + unit proof + maintainer waiver.
Preserve iMessage SMS reply routes for approval replies so a direct SMS /approve response can acknowledge and return results to the same SMS conversation.
Verification: gateway-only build, extension type checks, CI build-artifacts/check-prod-types/check-test-types/check-lint/check-additional-extension-package-boundary, and live prod iMessage SMS approval proof. checks-node-core-fast was waived by maintainer request after unrelated flaky failures in non-iMessage tests.
Fix iMessage native exec approval routing so approval prompts bind to the sent GUID without duplicate sends after RPC timeout. Also keeps chat.db GUID recovery on the local imsg path while avoiding local DB recovery for configured or detected SSH wrappers.
Thanks @kevinslin.
* fix(imessage): send group media via attachment command
* fix(imessage): preserve media rpc fallback
---------
Co-authored-by: Omar Shahine <10343873+omarshahine@users.noreply.github.com>
* feat(imessage): support thumb approval reactions
Mirrors openclaw#85477 (WhatsApp) for the iMessage channel. iMessage can now
deliver exec/plugin approval prompts via the existing imsg/BlueBubbles
transport and resolve approvals from 👍 (allow-once) / 👎 (deny) tapbacks.
Allow-always remains on the manual /approve <id> allow-always fallback.
What changed:
- New approval surfaces under extensions/imessage/src/:
approval-auth.ts, approval-resolver.ts, approval-reactions.ts,
approval-handler.runtime.ts, approval-native.ts (+ tests for each).
- channel.ts wires base.approvalCapability to the new iMessage capability.
- send.ts appends the 👍/👎 hint to outbound /approve prompts and registers
the reaction binding (keyed by accountId + chat_guid/chat_identifier/
chat_id/handle + messageId) after a successful send.
- monitor/monitor-provider.ts resolves approval reactions ahead of the
normal inbound decision pipeline so resolution bypasses
reactionNotifications gating and runs its own actor authorization.
- runtime.ts now exports getIMessageRuntime / getOptionalIMessageRuntime so
approval-reactions can open a persistent keyed store for binding state
across gateway restarts.
What did NOT change:
- Core approval surfaces in src/gateway/server-methods/* and src/infra/*
remain channel-agnostic; the channels.imessage.allowFrom field already
exists and is reused as the approver list for reactions.
- Other channels and the manual /approve sender-authorized path are
untouched.
* fix(imessage): address codex review findings on thumb approvals
Addresses 15 findings from the multi-angle codex review:
Critical (correctness / blocking):
- Register CHANNEL_APPROVAL_NATIVE_RUNTIME_CONTEXT_CAPABILITY in the iMessage
monitor so the gateway can actually deliver native approval prompts via
approval-handler.runtime.ts (it was dead code without the context lease).
- DM tapback approvals never resolved because send keyed by handle while
inbound preferred chat_guid. Register and look up under EVERY available
conversation key (chat_guid / chat_identifier / chat_id / handle); inbound
probes them all and accepts the first hit.
- Reaction binding now requires the bridge's GUID string (rejecting numeric
ROWIDs) so the binding key matches inbound reacted_to_guid.
- Outbound regex now requires both a canonical `ID: <approvalId>` header AND
a matching `/approve <id> <decision>` line, so non-approval messages that
legitimately mention /approve syntax no longer get a phantom reaction
binding (and can no longer resolve a colliding live approval).
- Drop is_from_me reaction events so cross-device echoes of the operator's
own tap cannot self-approve when their handle is in allowFrom.
High (operability / cleanup):
- Non-ApprovalNotFound errors now log at warn via the runtime child logger
(no longer hidden behind OPENCLAW_LOG_LEVEL=debug).
- In-memory binding is cleared on successful resolve so a toggle 👍→👎 (or
chat.db replay) does not refire and emit a misleading 'expired approval'
log line. Removed tapbacks are also owned by the shortcut and not surfaced
as noisy reaction system events.
- Move resolveIMessageReactionContext (and its helpers) to a slim
monitor/reaction-context.ts so approval-reactions.ts no longer transitively
pulls monitor/inbound-processing.ts (14+ heavy runtime modules) into the
hot channel.ts entrypoint per extensions/CLAUDE.md.
Medium (consistency / future-proofing):
- Native runtime exec pending payload now passes agentId, ask, and
sessionKey through buildExecApprovalPendingReplyPayload so the two
delivery routes produce identical operator-visible prompts.
- Both delivery paths now use addIMessageApprovalReactionHintToText (single
insertion point after ID:) so the hint cannot be double-emitted by the
native runtime path bypassing the idempotency guard.
- Extract replaceApprovalIdPlaceholder into a shared approval-text.ts that
escapes `$` in the replacement string so an approvalId containing
`$&`/`$1`-`$9`/`$$` cannot interpolate into the outbound text.
- In-memory Map now stores TTL alongside each entry and prunes expired
bindings on each register so the gateway no longer accumulates an
unbounded reaction-target Map.
- bindPending refuses to bind when accountId is missing or the approval is
already expired, with explicit error logs instead of silent no-ops.
- Reject chat_id=0 as a synthetic key value (chat.db ROWIDs start at 1).
- Drop dead getIMessageRuntime export — only the optional accessor is used.
Documentation:
- docs/channels/imessage.md gains an 'Approval reactions (👍 / 👎)' accordion
documenting the reaction emoji map, allowFrom approver requirement, the
/approve <id> allow-always manual fallback, and the deliberate change to
/approve command authorization for users with non-empty allowFrom.
- CHANGELOG.md entry added under 2026.5.24.
Tests: 411 iMessage tests pass (was 406). Added explicit coverage for the
DM key-mismatch fix, the regex-tightening fix, the is_from_me guard, the
clear-on-success behavior, and the approval-id `$` escape.
* test(imessage): match WhatsApp approval-native test coverage
Backfills the nine cases from extensions/whatsapp/src/approval-native.test.ts
that weren't mirrored in iMessage:
- target-mode exec + plugin prompt rendering with the canonical hint
- target-mode availability when no iMessage target matches
- agentFilter / sessionFilter applied to native handling
- account-scoped target enabled/disabled per account
- shouldSuppressForwardingFallback session-origin exact-match cases
- shouldSuppressForwardingFallback off when native cannot bind (locks down
the targets-only forwarding path the Lobster live deploy exercised)
- both-mode explicit + unscoped target suppression
- group-origin tapback approvals require explicit approvers
Tests: extensions/imessage/src/approval-native.test.ts 21 passed (was 11).
Total iMessage approval-specific cases now 49 (was 40).
* fix(imessage): preserve service-prefixed direct handles as approvers
ClawSweeper P1 review finding on #85952. normalizeIMessageApproverId was
calling looksLikeIMessageExplicitTargetId() to reject conversation-target
prefixes, but that helper also matches the imessage:/sms:/auto: service
prefixes — which are valid direct-handle forms. Any allowFrom entry like
'imessage:+15551230000' dropped to undefined, leaving approvers empty,
which:
- silently denied reaction resolution ('reactions require explicit
approvers'), and
- let text /approve fall back to implicit same-chat authorization.
Fix: normalize first via normalizeIMessageHandle (strips the service
prefix), then reject only chat_id:/chat_guid:/chat_identifier:
conversation-target shapes that remain after normalization.
Tests:
- approval-auth.test.ts: assert the resolved approver list contains the
normalized handle, plus the corollary that a non-matching sender is
explicitly rejected (no longer masked by the implicit-same-chat
fallback). Add a separate case covering chat_id/chat_guid/
chat_identifier rejection (with and without a service prefix).
- approval-reactions.test.ts: reaction resolution end-to-end with a
service-prefixed allowFrom entry — proves resolveIMessageApproval is
called rather than silently denied.
Focused suite: 48 passed (was 47).
* test(imessage): satisfy strict buildPendingPayload signature in render tests
CI check:test-types caught that the render.exec/render.plugin
buildPendingPayload calls were passing accountId (not in the type
signature). The signature is { cfg, request, target, nowMs }. Replace
accountId with target on the four render-test sites so the strict
test-types pass matches the SDK contract:
- it('renders thumbs-only reaction hints in exec approval prompts')
- it('renders thumbs-only reaction hints in plugin approval prompts ...')
- it('renders target-mode exec prompts with concrete thumbs-only ...')
- it('renders target-mode plugin prompts with concrete thumbs-only ...')
Verified locally with pnpm check:test-types (tsgo:core:test +
tsgo:extensions:test). 49 approval-specific tests still pass.
* fix(imessage): probe every tapback GUID form for approval lookup
ClawSweeper P1 review finding on #85952. readApprovalReactionEvent was
only using reaction.targetGuid (the first/normalized form), but
resolveIMessageReactionContext produces reaction.targetGuids = [normalized,
raw] for both `abc-123` and `p:0/abc-123` forms. If the imsg bridge
returned 'p:0/<guid>' from send() and send.ts registered the binding under
that prefixed key, the inbound resolver probing only the unprefixed form
would miss and the tapback would silently fall through.
Fix:
- Surface every GUID candidate in IMessageApprovalReactionEvent
(messageIdCandidates).
- maybeResolveIMessageApprovalReaction now probes each candidate in
precedence order; first hit wins.
- On success / ApprovalNotFoundError, clear the binding under all
candidate keys so toggle/replay does not refire.
Tests: extensions/imessage/src/approval-reactions.test.ts gains a
'resolves a reaction when the binding was registered under a p:0/…
prefixed GUID and the tapback surfaces both forms' regression case;
22/22 reaction tests pass. Full iMessage suite: 424/424.
* fix(imessage): native approval binding requires GUID, not numeric id
ClawSweeper third P1 review finding on #85952. approval-handler.runtime.ts
deliverPending was using result.messageId as the approval-reaction binding
key, but that field can be a numeric ROWID coerced to a string ('12345')
when the imsg bridge returns only message_id. Inbound tapbacks carry
reacted_to_guid which is always a GUID, so a numeric-id binding can never
match.
Fix mirrors the send.ts forwarding-path treatment:
- IMessageSendResult now exposes a separate guid?: string field, populated
from the same resolveOutboundMessageGuid helper send.ts already uses for
the forwarding-path binding. The generic messageId field is unchanged so
reply-cache, echo-cache, and receipt-building paths still see the
broadest id form.
- deliverPending now binds against result.guid; when it's undefined (numeric
ROWID or 'ok'/'unknown' placeholders), the function returns null instead
of binding against an id the inbound tapback can't possibly match.
Tests: approval-handler.runtime.test.ts gets a deliverPending GUID-only
binding describe block with three regression cases (numeric ROWID refused,
GUID accepted, ok/unknown placeholders refused). vi.mock isolates
sendMessageIMessage so the cases run synchronously without spawning imsg.
11 tests pass across handler.runtime + send specs.
---------
Co-authored-by: Omar Shahine <10343873+omarshahine@users.noreply.github.com>
Keep media-only iMessage sends from delivering visible <media:image> text while preserving a non-visible echo key for self-echo dedupe. Thanks @homer-byte.
* fix(imessage): prevent self-chat dedupe false positives (#47830)
Move echo cache remember() to post-send only, add early return when
inbound message ID doesn't match cached IDs (prevents text-based
false positives in self-chat), and reduce text TTL from 5s to 3s.
Three targeted changes to fix silent user message loss in self-chat:
1. deliver.ts: Remove pre-send remember() call — cache only reflects
successfully-delivered content, not pre-send full text.
2. echo-cache.ts: Skip text fallback when inbound has a valid message ID
that doesn't match any cached outbound ID. In self-chat, sender == target
so scopes collide; a user message with a fresh ID but matching text was
incorrectly dropped as an echo.
3. echo-cache.ts: Reduce text TTL from 5000ms to 3000ms — agent echoes
arrive within 1-2s, 5s was too wide.
Adds self-chat-dedupe.test.ts (7 tests) + updates deliver.test.ts.
BlueBubbles uses a different cache pattern — no changes needed there.
Closes#47830
* review(imessage): strip debug logs, bump echo TTL to 4s (#47830)
Bruce Phase 4 review changes:
- Remove all [IMSG-DEBUG] console.error calls from inbound-processing.ts
and monitor-provider.ts (23 lines, left over from Phase 2 debug deploy)
- Bump SENT_MESSAGE_TEXT_TTL_MS from 3s to 4s in echo-cache.ts to give
~2s margin above the observed 2.2s echo arrival time under load
- Update TTL tests to reflect 4s TTL (expired at 5s, live at 3s)
* fix(imessage): add dedupe comments and canary/compat/TTL tests
* fix(imessage): address review feedback on echo cache, shadowing, and test IDs
* refactor(imessage): hoist inboundMessageId to eliminate duplicate computation (#47830)
* fix(imessage): unify self-chat echo matching
* fix: use inbound guid for self-chat echo matching (#55359) (thanks @rmarr)
---------
Co-authored-by: Rohan Marr <rmarr@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-authored-by: Ayaan Zaidi <hi@obviy.us>
Peter Steinberger